Multi-Category Retail Partner
Mid-market e-commerce retailer, Shopify Plus. Engaged post-launch, after an independent Shopify 2.0 migration had already gone live and organic performance had already started to fall.
Phase 01 · The Crash
Same URLs. Same products.
Different rankings entirely.
The client migrated independently to leverage native app blocks, dynamic sections and faster load times. The URL architecture stayed identical — but organic performance fell within days of launch.
| Metric | Pre-migration | Day 30 | Variance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly organic sessions | 125,000 | 72,500 | −42% |
| Organic conversion rate | 2.1% | 1.8% | −14.2% |
| Weekly blended revenue | $85,000 | $55,250 | −35% |
| Keywords ranking top 3 | 42 | 11 | −73.8% |
Phase 02 · Forensic Audit
Four template-level
points of failure.
We diffed the archived Shopify 1.0 repository against the live 2.0 theme. The damage wasn't in the migration plan — it was in what the new template quietly left out.
The legacy theme hardcoded category descriptions and FAQs directly into
collection.liquid. The new JSON-based collection.json template
omitted those blocks entirely — category pages kept the product grid and lost everything else.
Impact: loss of topical authority on high-volume category terms.
The 1.0 theme injected Product and Breadcrumb schema via a dedicated app. The 2.0 theme's native schema blocks conflicted with that same app script, outputting duplicate, fragmented, invalid JSON-LD.
Impact: rich snippets (stars, price, availability) disappeared from SERPs; CTR collapsed.
In the new banner component, the dynamic <h1> was
assigned to an optional promo slide widget instead of the Product or Collection title.
Pages loaded with missing or duplicated H1s.
Impact: immediate devaluation of page relevance by Googlebot.
Native storefront filtering shipped without strict self-referencing
canonical logic. Google began indexing thousands of duplicate, parameterised URLs
(e.g. ?filter.p.m.custom.color=Blue).
Impact: crawl-budget exhaustion and index bloat.
Phase 03 · The 14-Day Sprint
Patch the template.
Don't touch the theme.
The brief wasn't to reverse the migration — it was to make Shopify 2.0 work the way it was supposed to, without losing the speed gains that justified the upgrade.
Replaced hardcoded 1.0 text fields with native Shopify 2.0 metafields (custom.seo_description, custom.faq_data) and injected them back into the collection.json layout dynamically.
Disabled the legacy third-party snippet code and reconfigured the theme's liquid files to output a single, valid structured-data payload compliant with Schema.org.
Re-engineered main-product.liquid and main-collection.liquid to guarantee one semantic H1 per page, reserved exclusively for the primary entity name.
Implemented strict self-referencing canonicals across collection variants and updated Search Console parameter handling to ignore storefront filter variables.
Phase 04 · Recovery
Not just a rebound.
A better baseline.
Google Search Console showed impressions stabilise within days of the sprint shipping, then a full rebound in keyword position. The page-speed gain the client migrated for finally started paying off once the underlying markup stopped fighting it.
A theme upgrade is not just a cosmetic change. It's a structural database migration.Key takeaway, Dolphin Digital remediation report
Dolphin Digital
Migrating your theme?
Audit it before you launch.
We run staging-environment audits of semantic HTML, structured data and index control before the switch goes live — so this becomes a case study you read, not one you star in.
Get Audit →See Our Success Stories
Words From Our Clients
I would highly recommend Dolphin Digital for any brands looking to grow. Proven results and the benefits of their blended strategy methodology across our multiple DTC brands has been impressive — with very high accountability.
Simon BurnettHead of Brand · Zen Imports — Ledlenser — Fjallraven — LeathermanA fantastic partner for our CRM refresh. They strengthened our Klaviyo email ecosystem from flow strategy through to design and execution — retention, trust, re-engagement, win-back, replenishment and anniversary.
Richard HirstHead of eCommerce · Taylors WinesWorking with the team on our ESP migration to Klaviyo was seamless. They were always transparent with information, reporting, updates and needs — like an extension of our team.
Heather EarleCommerce & Digital Marketing Manager · Nutrition WarehouseFrom start to finish, their team has been nothing short of outstanding. They took the time to really understand our business and crafted a marketing strategy that exceeded our expectations.
These guys know what they are doing. From the get go we have found them to be very thorough and understanding of our limited digital marketing knowledge.
Tony TitleyChief Executive Officer · W. Titley & CoThe experienced team went above and beyond to assist with the SEO piece of the migration and I would highly recommend them.
Mikhyla DudleyHead of eComm · HavaianasGreat service provider, very knowledgable and responsive.
If you’re looking to invest in your eCommerce digital marketing, you won’t regret bringing Dolphin Digital on board. The entire team are veterans in their field.
Let Our Team Of Ecommerce Specialists Help You Achieve Elite Digital Experiences & Growth
Bring us the storefront, the channel mix, and the commercial goal. We'll return a clear diagnosis and the plays that move revenue.
Contact Us
Free · $4,500 value
Gain insights on how to optimise your digital channels
A complimentary eCommerce audit — delivered in 5 working days.